This is a companion entry to my column in this morning’s Herald & Review.
This is an e-mail I recently sent to friends:
“A recent article on theonion.com avclub.com discussed which artists get a lifetime pass from you. This is the artist(s) or performer(s) who, regardless of whatever they do, you will like them and continue to enjoy, appreciate and pursue their work.
“Who is yours?
“Don’t feel like you have to limit it to one. If film is your passion and there are three actors or directors, that’s fine. If you want to pick an author, someone from film or TV and someone from music, that’s great. I’m just looking for a cross-section of selections. I will be surprised if the same name shows up three times based on the 30 people I’m sending this out to.”
Here are the responses of those who chose to give details. (Not everyone did.) I’m leaving off the respondents’ names, mainly to protect the guy who listed both Milla Jovovich and Jean Claude Van Damme.
***
Billy Corgan, Smashing Pumpkins
I started listening to the Smashing Pumpkins in the 1990s in high school, so for me, their early albums are almost more about time than music. I followed Billy through the Smashing Pumpkins’ downward spiral to Zwan to a short-lived solo career and back again to the Pumpkins. I bought every album, but I’ve only seen him twice - both as part of Zwan. I don’t know why, but every time I get a new album of his, it all starts out the same - I hate every song at first. To be truthful, I really don’t even like his voice. But then after a few listens, a cold familiarity starts to grow in me, and I can appreciate how he sings about things that I understand.
***
In music, my lifetime passes go to Bob Dylan, Bruce Springsteen, Neil Young and Pete Townshend. Each of them has written and produced music that attracted me from the very beginning. Each of them grew and had different phases. I didn’t like all phases, but understood there was change and the experimentation that usually led to something else that was really phenomenal. Granted, I know some of that loses fans, but would there have been “Tommy” without “A Quick One”?
How each progressed through their careers differs, in my opinion, from someone like Tom Petty. “Damn the Torpedoes” is one of the best albums ever, but Petty didn’t really progress anywhere unless doing a duet with Stevie Nicks counts.
But Dylan, Springsteen, Young and Townshend aren’t afraid to explore new genres or approaches. Petty stayed on the same path and rarely moved.
Springsteen ended up alienating some fans with “Nebraska” in the 1980s and the recent, “We Shall Overcome: The Seeger Sessions.” But I rate both of them high in my estimation. In fact, I prefer the Seeger sessions over either of his two most recent releases. And for the record, my favorite Springsteen album is either “Darkness on the Edge of Town” or “Tunnel of Love,” depending on my mood.
I have a similar esteem for Young. There are a lot of artists who would have lost me during a techno-babble phase, as Young had in the 1980s, but I also figured he would move on eventually and he did.
The main thing is that each of these artists I will take the time to listen to their new releases. And I can’t tell you the last time I went out of my way to listen to the newest thing Tom Petty was doing, no matter how much I love “Damn the Torpedoes.”
I have flimsier experience in film, but my passes here go to the Coen Brothers and Jack Nicholson. I know the Coens have put out some movies lately that haven’t been the greatest, but I still give them a try. They came to my attention with the underrated “Raising Arizona.” And while I really liked “Fargo,” they hooked me hard on “The Big Lebowski.” I probably liked “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” better than a lot of people, but I keep coming back.
Nicholson is Nicholson. He’s interesting to me because he isn’t afraid to play a slob or lowlife. His acting is almost not acting it seems so natural.
***
I tried to think of an actor I appreciate in more than a couple roles… someone whose name in a preview makes me think I may want to check out the movie (and not simply because said actor is good-looking). And the first two that come to my mind are Reese Witherspoon and Kate Winslet. I think these two have both proven that they are versatile actors and I’ve yet to see one of their movies where I was actually disappointed in their individual performances. Kate Winslet also won me over when she made a statement against being airbrushed in photo shoots.
Musically, I’m going to have to go with Rascal Flatts. I enjoy everything they do, with the exception of one or two songs, which I appreciate but don’t necessarily like. I’ve also seen them several times in concert and, while some sets are definitely better than others, I have never regretted going.
I was trying to think of an author or two, but as much as I like reading, there is no one author I can honestly say has earned a lifetime pass for me. I enjoy Grisham, but there are a handful of books I don’t care for, too many to ignore. I have read all three of Mitch Albom’s novels (Tuesdays with Morrie, The Five People You’ll Meet in Heaven and For One More Day), and have been touched by each. However, as I’ve never read any of his articles or other such commentary, I don’t know how I feel about these non-novel endeavors, and I don’t feel I can give a lifetime pass to someone whose works I’m not entirely familiar with. Also, because he’s only written those three novels, and I can’t really find evidence that there are more coming, I’m not sure he’d even need a lifetime pass, as his novel-writing lifetime may have already passed.
***
Joss Whedon — After Buffy the Vampire Slayer, he can do no wrong! I will at least watch the new stuff he writes, directs or produces. I may not find the some of his stuff entertaining, but I am assured it will always be innovative
George Lucas — Though I must admit I became a bit irritated with him with his constant insistence on “reworking” the original trilogies to add in the flashier special effects. The first two movies of the Star Wars prequels were also just a special effects fest. In “The Revenge of the Sith” the special effects actually helped make the story and didn’t overpower it. Just when you think he’s learned his lesson, though, he comes up with “The Clone Wars” animated series. Go figure.
Jamie Lee Curtis — She’s multitalented (author, actress). She’s cool; She’s not afraid to show that a woman in her 50s can look fantastic and doesn’t have to buy into that whole get a facelift, dye your hair thing. I can even forgive her for the “Activia Lady” gig. Hey, you gotta be regular!
***
The Muppets – Since Jim Henson passed, it seems like The Muppets have had more downs than ups. But no matter what; I’ll take The Muppets anytime, anywhere, and enjoy them no matter what.
PIXAR – How many hits have they had in a row? Strike that. How many QUALITY hits have they had in a row? Even the ones that aren’t AS good as the others (Cars, A Bug’s Life) are still incredibly good and heads and tails above other films. Not above other animated films, but other films period. I don’t care where they go from here, I’ll happily follow them no matter what.
***
I would have to say McCartney. I’ve been frustrated with him many times, and I long ago stopped automatically buying everything he puts out, but at the same time, he has given me so much enjoyment for 45 years that I find it hard to dismiss him.
***
My list of musicians could be a lot longer, because I’m like a Labrador retriever with musical artists I like. If I ever liked them, I almost always KEEP liking them forever. I get tired of actors and authors but I never get tired of my favorite recording artists no matter how many eggs they lay. And let’s face it, even Sir Paul lays one occasionally.
***
In books, Cormac McCarthy and Salman Rushdie cannot be defeated, even if they defeat themselves. In movies, Clint Eastwood is incapable of wrongdoing. The last movie he made that was only okay was “Blood Work,” and everything since then has stretched the boundaries of the maximum legal allotment of awesome within a 2 hour period on celluloid. Also, and people will probably think I’m a fool, Jack Black is canonized. He frequently makes less-than-wise decisions, but “Shallow Hal” and “School of Rock” were two comedies that are really the only ones I can think of that aren’t outright mean-spirited. He actually reminds me a lot of Bill Murray (who also gets a lifetime pass), because he’s got that underlying sincerity to his comedy that makes you sympathize with his characters instead of merely laugh at them.
In comics, I guess I give it to Alan Moore, even if he DOES insist on writing “Lost Girls” (which in all fairness, I haven’t read).
In animation (and guys who will be summoned at the sound of the trumpet to destroy evil in the great war to come), Brad Bird gets a pass due to “The Iron Giant,” “Ratatouille,” and particularly due to “The Incredibles,” which is the only “family film” that’s been in theaters since I want to say “Back to the Future.” Don Bluth gets the other one for a variety of reasons, and because maybe people giving him lifetime passes would incite him to MAKE ANOTHER MOVIE.